More of my "2 cents" if interested
More of my "2 cents" if interested
Thursday, January 01, 2009
Tezza,
Wow all of these posts so fast! You and your topic are sure popular.
Some further thoughts on my posting and the others about your “new” Kaypro and disk drive issues.
My original post was just a “quickie” to help you out ASAP, so you did not waste too much time and get into too much frustration, even though as a hobby, it can be a lot of fun – “a labor of love” as so many have said.
So glad you finally got one! We had emailed each other a few times in the past.
Things look like they are working out for you, but you and others may have future disk drive and other issues develop, so I offer the following.
We can PM each other if more details are needed, since this post is already so long.
If anyone is interested, continue reading. If not, just move on.
========================================================
With vintage computers, as in so many other areas, there are many unknowns and possible unintentional consequences.
So please note that if you decide to make use of any of the information I provide, including in this and any other postings, in addition to my web site, then you use it
“only and completely at your own risk.”
All this is offered in “good faith” and I can have no liability in any form and any way, including many of the other standard disclaimers. It is the best I know at the present time from the information I have. If you cannot accept this, then do not use this information.
Also note, that many beginners may not be aware of the possibility of harmful and even lethal electrical hazards with your computer activities, especially when you open your computer case. There can be other hazards also, so be careful and get sufficiently informed.
You may even want to hire an appropriate and qualified professional in such matters.
========================================================
Erik, as the webmaster, if any of this is not appropriate just delete, move, etc. any and all of it as you see fit. I do not want to clutter up the site unnecessarily.
An idea – another section on your web site like an “Archive” for such longer and more detailed posts? By the way, love how you keep upgrading the site – many thanks from all of us!
========================================================
I will eventually post such things as this on my web site, but this is quicker. I use an outside web service and it takes awhile to update the site and there is some expense involved.
Also, this thread may become very useful for others who have similar Kaypro drive & other issues. In addition, some may have their drives work fine after a fix and then other issues develop.
This thread may also help to reduce the number of inquiries and responses on some of the same questions some new Kaypro owners continue to have.
Some specific details -
1] If you want to be a “purist,” then you probably will stick with the Tandons. But for those who want to actually use their Kaypro systems a lot, then the Teacs are something to consider in order to not have to do so many repairs. After all, the real fun is using your Kaypros and not just looking at them.
2] I spent a great deal of time learning and repairing the Tandons, also using the Dyson and other diagnostic / alignment systems, etc., until the eventual upgrades and the 4 Teacs per system. I can just say that the responses you got all seem accurate from my experiences, as far as I can tell, but my memory may not be as sharp as from way back then.
3] I agree, the Tandons were not bad drives for their time, but time moves on and better options become available.
4] Naturally, there will always be conflicts of actual experiences for many reasons [“the law of unintentional, and many times unknown, consequences”].
5] Consequently, I have a collection of about 40 – 50 in our basement in all sorts of condition [great to just for parts!], but they are old and not professionally refurbished. So “new” – really professionally refurbished [I do not think you can get “real new” or “not used” any more] would be the best bet to save you a lot of frustration, time and effort. Also see below for some additional issues.
6] Tandons are still available at reasonable prices from Farris [see my post] and other posts on this web site. The 5.25” floppies are also available. You may want to try newer floppies, since I have seen some reports of the media breaking down with older and used floppies of that early era.
7] Who thought that around 25 years later these systems and floppies would still be in use!
8] Many reference documents may already be available as scanned downloads elsewhere. I know the Kaypro service manuals are available from a group in Britain. Erik knows about them.
9] A] Some may know a lot of this, but from my experience with this so excellent web site so far and with vintage computing in general, many probably do not.
B] So much to learn and so little time!
C] Where can you go to get such great technical information so quickly from so many people worldwide and over the holidays yet! This web site is similar to our local computer group - Lehigh Valley Computer Group.
========================================================
10] As most long time Kaypro users know, the main issues with the Kaypros were the soldering on the power supplies and the Tandon drives. Otherwise, what great machines!
11] The soldering issue was rather simple to manage. Just remelt the main solder areas on the power supplies, especially for the connectors to other areas of the Kaypro. Micro Cornucopia indicated to me that this was about 90% of all the Kaypro issues that they dealt with at that time.
12] A] I cannot begin to tell you how hard my wife and I used our 6 Kaypros for almost 10 years in so many projects. Once I learned how to do my own work on them, I rarely had any issues after the upgrades to Kaypro “8” ‘ s stabilized and I was using new half height Teac drives. Heat was the main issue, since we were pushing the system well beyond what it was designed for. More details below.
B] With the Teac drives, when I started up all 6 Kaypro “8” ‘s last year at about this time to check them out, they all immediately came up, but naturally some a little slower than others, they read the disks in the drives and ran the software – after between 10 – 15 years in storage and not being used!
13] A] Some may not be aware that with only 64 K in RAM, there was a lot of swapping going on with the A drive for the software and even for the B drive, where you stored the files you were making. Thus, the A drive was usually the first to show issues. This sounds like what you found Tezza. You know computers well and knew the “swap” of the B drive for the A drive should be tried and it worked.
B] When I was doing big projects like extensive spreadsheets, the disk drives would continuously spin for 15 to 30 minutes swapping and / or storing data!!! What a workout! So while that was taking place, I worked on another project with a second Kaypro setup right next to the first Kaypro.
14] Another important aspect, especially with respect to future issues that may develop with a Kaypro, there are many variations of even the same model due to possible last minute undocumented production changes [no ISO 9000 then] while they were built. Kaypro got pretty chaotic and hectic at times and some models may contain items that are not contained in other units of that same model due to many reasons [e.g., use up spare parts, run out of certain parts, errors, etc.]. Quality control / assurance [QC/QA] must have been a nightmare then. More details below.
15] A] But Careful inspection of your particular Kaypro may speak volumes, if you know what to look for. We can all help each other in this regard.
B] Unless you know about many of these details on just what specific Kaypro model and version you have, along with any modifications that may have been made, then it will be very difficult to try to effectively and efficiently deal with any future issues that may develop.
C] By the way, how did you get it, or maybe you cannot tell us [a midnight requisition? – but knowing you, I don’t think you are into that!]. Do you know any details of its past history that could provide some clues for this and other issues that may develop in the future?
16] A] 1] First a picture “speaks a 1000 words” – thanks for providing one - your drives are mounted vertical, rather than the more common horizontal. Looks like there is no drive shield also. Also drives mounted with bottom of drives towards CRT and power supply, which can protect their circuit boards and circuits better from any electrical interference.
2] USA FCC hammered TRS-80’s in this regard and all had to be
eventually recalled. Apple also had this issue and they were able to economically manage it eventually. So it can be an important but variable issue.
B] 1] Front configuration of other items – LED and knob [brightness control ? – but usually on the back panel] are different – at top and not down side of CRT – was this series made for just New Zealand? You said TRS-80’s were different in your country than in the USA and were called “Dick Smith System 80’s”.
2] I found some Kaypros have a Netherlands address on the back. I
have one and so does Erik. But otherwise they seem the same.
C] These are all “tip offs” that your Kaypro may be different from many standard others. Did someone do some modifications? This may not be important now, since you seem to have your disk drives presently under control, but may become significant when future issues develop.
D] More pictures can help, especially of the cover, back panel and close up of main board. Also, what is the serial number [S/N] on the back panel?
E] Compare your Kaypro to the many pictures of my Kaypros on my web site under the folder “Special” – I did a 2008 calendar with many such pictures. Check the main board chip layout and chip numbers and socket “U” numbers especially. But keep in mind that they were modified in certain areas to Kaypro “8” ‘s however. I can provide more details, if needed.
F] I put these pictures and draft of my book on my web site since we still do not have DSL / broadband in our very rural area yet. Such big MB downloads can take from ½ to over an hour to upload or download.
17] A] Looks like you are taking the drives out to check how they perform while you make adjustments. Sometimes when you put them back into the computer, they do not work – can be a sign of interference from the rest of the computer, among many other issues.
B] You may also want to put the cover back on before you test to see if the drives are working after you fix them. With all the electronic stuff we have in our homes today, some may cause some interference. I had some even back in the 1990’s. Kaypro was smart using a heavy duty aluminum metal case for many reasons!
18] A] Looks like your main board has chips at U43 and U47 with the usual white stickers on them. They can be a key as to what particular Kaypro you really have.
B] Sharkonwheels on this web site will know a lot more – Shark if you are reading this, correct me if I made any errors. I am sure you will help Tezza and other people, since that is just the kind of guy you are.
C] If U47 Monitor ROM has a white sticker on it indicating 81-232, then you have a Kaypro 4 “at heart”, even though the outside case says you have a Kaypro II [note not “2” – that can be another issue]. If you can locate a Micro Cornucopia Pro-8 chip, then you can change and add different drives at will, if you ever want to upgrade.
D] Note U43 Character ROM can be another different issue.
E] 1] Shark and others may even be able to “make” such chips for you, although there may be legal and other issues involved and he will certainly need to be compensated in some substantial way for such specialized services.
F] If U47 is 81-149 [possibly a “C” after it also, an “A” or a “B” version has some history of issues surrounding them] then you have a Kaypro II.
G] If it is 81-292-A, then you have a Kaypro 4, but a 1984 year
version. This may be able to be upgraded to 4 disk drives using the currently still available Advent system. Check with Sharkonwheels on this web site – he is an expert on the 1984 Kaypros – I am more into the 1983’s.
19] A] Note also the main board designation for the year 1983’s is 81-240, 81-184 or 81-110 {obsolete – but I have one I believe} [may be on back of board on lower right side when look at top of board].
B] If the board number is 81-184, it is a 1984 year computer.
C] Note some of these boards and or U47 chips can use different versions of CP / M.
D] Note also that there are a variety of Kaypro “ 2 ’ s ” - 2X, 2/84, New 2, etc.
E] Kaypro “ II “ is usually for the 1983 year computers.
F] There are many Kaypro 4 versions. There is even a Kaypro “1” used as a prototype only, if you ever wondered about that number designation. One of the later Kaypro “2” ‘ s was actually a “II “ and produced using a lot of old spare parts, just to get some much needed funds as they approached bankruptcy probably . Osborne apparently did this also. Many others probably did and still do.
G] There is much confusion about all these designations, chips, main boards, CP / M’s, etc., so be careful.
H] I have gotten many inquiries and it is difficult for some to accept that it was just that way in early computing. Another motivation for this long document is to help others who are in such a situation – it can help keep down the traffic in responding about the same issue over and over again. They can just go to this posting for the info.
I] But today, we have some similarities – Win 95, Win 98, Win ME, Win XP, Vista, etc. and now the new Windows 7 is coming – all leading to many compatibility issues.
J] Naturally, if you do not have the right CP / M versions, then even if your disk drives are ok, you cannot boot! Be grateful you have the right boot disk [many do not] and that it works with your Kaypro.
20] A] 1] A Micro Cornucopia article noted that the floppy disk controller [FDC1793, at socket U82] and / or the data separator [FDC 9216, at socket U88] can be issues. Some of these may still be available at JDR Electronics in California.
2] But beware of export restrictions! Will you get a knock on the door
by home security? Probably not, but ……….- who needs the grief!
3] Also there may be some custom duties. There are some posts on
www.classiccmp.org email distribution that some shippers will back charge the person who shipped the items for any such duties, if they are not paid by the recipient.
B] 1] a] JDR also still has many of the other Kaypro main board chips, including the Z80’s – CPU, PIO and SIO very cheaply [less than $1 each, even just $0.25], since they were and I guess still are, so commonly used.
b] Also check the versions of these Z80 chips you have –
Z80A, Z80B, etc. These are faster chips and may generate excess heat, which can show up after you have run your computer for a few hours. Then the “fun” begins – lockups, shutdowns, disk drive issues and other erratic behavior.
2] If you have a “real “1983 Kaypro II and they are A’s or B’s, then
someone may have done some upgrades on your Kaypro. They should just be Z80’s with no other letters added. Other Kaypro versions / models may have the “letter” designated versions – up to eventually “H” I believe.
C] Apparently, Kaypro got a big batch of bad data separators that caused a lot of long term issues.
D] In fact, I published a short note in Micro Cornucopia in 1987 on two of my upgraded Kaypros that eventually failed because of these 1793 chips, probably due to the heat issues involved with stressing the basic design of the system with these upgrades. It was one of my similar short publications to help others from my experiences.
E] 1] These Micro Cornucopia [MC] upgrades were just great, with very complete and understandable directions and quality parts, but you were really pushing the system way beyond what they were originally designed for, so there were some “break-in” issues that developed.
2] One was this heat generation, so if you have an upgraded Kaypro,
be aware of this. Comically, it was discovered when we put the tops back on our Kaypros. The people designing the upgrades never did this, since they were always “tinkering” with their systems. That is why I added a fan and even a perforated aluminum top to help cool them. Then all was fine.
E] One MC article even recommends just replacing the Tandons with half height good quality Japanese drives. It is easy and quite inexpensive. But I may note that there are some other considerations – setting the jumpers correctly, twisting the drive cables correctly, etc. But overall, no big deal if you are aware of these issues.
21] A] One of the best source of Kaypro technical information are the Micro Cornucopia journals of course. If they could be scanned and made available, it would be a great service.
B] Unfortunately, in our continuing downsizing in retirement, many years ago I could never have imagined I would ever need these journals again. We had moved on to Gateways, Compaqs, Gateways, Toshibas, etc. So they were tossed into the dumpster, along with much else from that era.
C] I do have some of the main articles, but they are marked up with my notes. In addition, it would be a big scanning job to do. Then there are the legal issues and how best to make them available and archived at a central location. Many are struggling with such issues for many computers today. Hopefully they will be eventually resolved in a satisfactory manner.
22] A] Also, another consideration of that era is the concept of “hypergrowth” that Osborne coined and is the title of his book on his company. I bring out some of this in the draft of my book on that era – “a computer built every 5 minutes!”.
B] For perspective, Tandon was selling “28,000 disk drives a month” to Kaypro alone! So right there you have a great potential for at least some bad drives getting into the system. Did you get one and others did not?
C] So some may be disappointed with some “issues” they may face with their Kaypros and other vintage computers, but for perspective, it is a miracle that so many were made so well and still work today from that early and so new era of computing!
D] I can say that all the Kaypros we got, 2 were new, and the 4 others used, were and still are incredible working machines. So rugged and so well designed and made. Again, like the Tucker cars of the 1940’s. But things change and life moves on, but what could have been if they could have continued profitably?
========================================================
So that is it for now. Hope some of this is of some interest and use.
I encourage all to please return the favor and continue to offer your input so we can all benefit.
If there is enough interest, then a lot of this Kaypro stuff can be pursued more intensively and even put on my web site. But right now, my information indicates that we are a very small group, so we will just have to try to do the best we can.
With the present global economy situation, it may take several years before we all get back to a time when we have more disposable income to devote to our hobby and to more substantially preserving these vintage computers.
All the best for 2009 and thanks for your interest and keeping those Kaypros and other vintage computers running!
Frank
Some additional background info if you are interested –
Please keep in mind, I am not a computer “techie!” I learned on my own what I had to learn to keep our systems going – we had a big investment in so many ways to try to protect and extend the usefulness of their lives, until we eventually went to more modern windows systems.
Also, my research for the draft of my book on these early portable, personal computers [PPC’s] – Osborne, Kaypro, Compaq, IBM, etc.] provided much additional information.
The draft is available as a free download on my website under the folder “Special,” if you are interested. Two publishers are now reviewing it for possible publication. But with the global economy as it is, I doubt either will be able to publish it. So I will eventually publish it on my own using our computer and inexpensive laser black and white printer. Any funds from such a publication will just go to fund my continuing STS research, which of course, includes vintage computers.
Please note that some of the files on this website, including this draft, got corrupted recently and when downloaded, appeared to be just simple text that was not very sophisticated and understandable. If this happens again, just let me know and I will have the web site provider fix it again.
Also, please ignore any “typos,” since I already spent a lot of time on this. But my wife is an English major and has very high standards!