Greetings. I too have been spending the last couple of weeks attempting to repair a PET to working order, although this time an original 2001-8 (chiclet keyboard with built in tape drive). I'm a software engineer with a semester or so experience working on digital hardware and basic soldering skills, but a strong desire to learn and stubbornness to bring back a childhood first computer experience.
I've made some good progress with the help of resources on the web to get me started, especially Matthew's article at
http://www.dasarodesigns.com/projects/troubleshooting-common-problems-with-the-commodore-pet-2001/
Also, I bought a composite video adapter board from him so I could remove the CRT and boot many times without harm to it. The CRT itself seemed ok.
My progress so far:
Computer initially booted up to basic with vertical lines through all columns of the screen or stuck at initial screen full of random chars, not all RAM recognized, keyboard nearly non-functioning. I found a picture of the exact vertical line issue on the web link above and explanation which pointed to a Video ROM problem!
While removing and cleaning all socketed chips, I found a bent pin on one, 3 broken pins on the video ROM and very weak pins that broke off on a system ROM when I lightly fine sand papered it (I was told don't use sand paper again, use an eraser) (all gold colored pins interestingly). I painstakingly soldered pins on the chips (really hard for me to keep 'em on), good for one insertion only I found out, and the video problem was fixed and system boot more stable!
For the keyboard I applied a pencil eraser to the conductive key plungers, used contact cleaner, swapped around working plungers to more important keys, and finally used product called Wire Glue to dab on the worst ones. Keyboard fixed, all buttons working!
Then while checking the power supply I found a bad voltage regulator (0 v). I replaced it, which not easy for me, having trouble desoldering, but struggled through it. After replacing the regulator all existing RAM was recognized (only 4K is installed) and attaching a cassette deck and using it didn't crash the computer anymore! Perhaps the additional current draw of the cassette deck made the regulator give up its ghost.
I started going forward using the tape deck and loading the breakout program and it worked! However then I had a setback. The computer boots up fine when completely cold. After a while the computer would hang with a print out of illegal quantity error and then will not boot passed the blank screen unless it is left off for a couple of hours. Using the tape drive to load a program seems to hasten this condition.
I decided to try removing the 6520 PIA chips during this failure state and found that with the keyboard one out the system would always boot to basic even albeit with no cursor and no keyboard function as expected. I bought a logic Probe and started checking lines. With this chip in during the hang the ram select lines are all high and the CPU address lines high as well. With the chip out select lines on ram show pulse waves and CPU address lines are pulsing rapidly more like normal. I swapped 6520 with the other one but no difference was observed so the chips seem good. I checked The integrity of the socket pins with an ohm meter to the back side of the board and found no issues.
Latest theory: Looks like I may have a thermally sensitive component or solder joint, although not sure where, but I suspect the I/O circuity down stream from the 6520. I'm planning to get some Super Cold to cool down areas when this happens. I don't have a heat gun which I heard is another option.
I'm open to advice. Please help if you have any suggestions. I'd like to get this thing back together and move on from this OCD episode!
Thanks a bunch!
Jim