Gonna go out on a limb here...but I actually really like the Cheetah Annihilator (cheap crappy 3 button joystick bundled with the C64GS). By the early 90's they were bundling them with C64Cs and it was my first Joystick. I found it really comfortable to use and despite lack of microswitches it seemed fairly accurate.
It's infamous reputation for shoddy build probably is fair enough as I did chew threw 2 or 3 of them in less than a year whilst the C64 was under warranty, any left probably aren't in very good condition.
For a better joystick, I really like the QuickJoy III Supercharger (which the Cheetah was replaced with after it failed out of warranty). Really nice microswitched design, very comfortable to use with enough resistance to be accurate but not so much that it is hard to move the stick around. Also has Autofire. Very solidly built for a low cost digital joystick. My example is over 25 years old and has taken a lot of abuse over the years, still works like new.