There is some truth in your analysis, however in my case it doesn't exactly fit. Druid referred to PCCs, (pshycopathic computer collectors), and I do have in effect more computers than I could possibly use. I also have more records than I could possibly play, more books than I could possibly re-read or read, and National Graphics that I rarely peruse.
Things that are there should I like to re-experience them. Is that a problem ? Am I depriving others of a sustaining means of life in the sense of food hoarders which is the perjorative sense of the term ?
The defining difference between the very rich who CAN hoard lifesaving things, should there not be a time of plenty, is the denial of sharing these necessary things. The compulsive aquisition of things by those with less financial means is a different thing even ignoring the fact that many collectors acquire their objects from the discards of others. At its best it is a symbol of respect for the workmen or artists who fashioned the object, as opposed to the wealthy acquirers who usually have no relation to the object and can toss it away when they lose interest and aquire a new interesting object.
Those who might acquire 50 of the same object for no reason, obviously have insecurity problems but are not common and are not collectors, but obsessives with mental problems. Not your usual collector even tho we might have several back-up copies of a treasured machine.
And the crowning moments of a collectors life is not in a "DEAL" but in a thrift shop discovery, a dumpster or trash find, an auction or yard sale treasure, a gift from friends.
And my house may not be minimalist decor, but it's the way I like it, full of interesting stuff. Just like the world around us. Not your cup of tea ? Tough ! Get over it.
Lawrence
I view collectors as people who want one of everything in one category, and hoarders are the ones who might have 50 of the same item for no real reason other then they can.
There is not that much difference between the very rich and hoarders other then a hoarder can't pass up a "deal" and the rich just amass money so they can buy what they want the second they want it. Either way they both end up with more stuff then they can generally use.