sombunall
Experienced Member
Hargle said this in "XT IDE Ordering interest?"
http://www.vintage-computer.com/vcforum/showthread.php?18242-XT-IDE-Ordering-interest-%28Was-Xt-ide&p=152879#post152879
snippet:
This situation has been bugging me for some time too. Why should Hargle not be compensated for his ongoing work? There should be some kind of a provision for this. The XTIDE is GPL v2 right? Is it really designed with hardware in mind?
One thing I could think of was a woman who released her music for free on the internet. Then she had a tiered system of donations in which a bigger donation got more extras. It went from sending a signed CD all the way to for $10,000 she would come and sing at your house personally. She actually made some money doing this as to make it feasable.
But how would this work for us? Somebody would pay Hargle $10,000 to come to their house to assemble an XTIDE in front of their face??? Ok maybe that's extreme but I was thinking something like this:
tier 1 : regular board
tier 2 : Silkscreen contains signatures of the most important people in the project
tier 3 : same as tier 2 except the board is blue instead of green
...and what if Hargle quit and then some other guy will do it but at a markup? Would that person be sued? Also does assemblage of parts fall under "support" the way Red Hat does and therefore not subject to the "not for profit" part of the GPL?
http://www.vintage-computer.com/vcforum/showthread.php?18242-XT-IDE-Ordering-interest-%28Was-Xt-ide&p=152879#post152879
snippet:
[
I really figured that with the 20 or so prototypes that we did, then the bulk run of 100 cards, that we'd totally tapped out the market for these things.
Boy was I wrong! Sales haven't slumped much at all. I think I've done 4 or 5 additional runs of 10 cards, and they keep disappearing. In fact I dipped into my personal stock just yesterday to fill an order.
My problem is that I honestly don't want to spend that much more time on this stuff. Yeah, it's a great card, but I want to try using one for a change instead of building + kitting them in my free time. I want to write that CD-ROM driver. I want to work on the PCjr version of it. I want to be able to go see a movie sometime.
]
This situation has been bugging me for some time too. Why should Hargle not be compensated for his ongoing work? There should be some kind of a provision for this. The XTIDE is GPL v2 right? Is it really designed with hardware in mind?
One thing I could think of was a woman who released her music for free on the internet. Then she had a tiered system of donations in which a bigger donation got more extras. It went from sending a signed CD all the way to for $10,000 she would come and sing at your house personally. She actually made some money doing this as to make it feasable.
But how would this work for us? Somebody would pay Hargle $10,000 to come to their house to assemble an XTIDE in front of their face??? Ok maybe that's extreme but I was thinking something like this:
tier 1 : regular board
tier 2 : Silkscreen contains signatures of the most important people in the project
tier 3 : same as tier 2 except the board is blue instead of green
...and what if Hargle quit and then some other guy will do it but at a markup? Would that person be sued? Also does assemblage of parts fall under "support" the way Red Hat does and therefore not subject to the "not for profit" part of the GPL?