• Please review our updated Terms and Rules here

Must everything we buy new today be disposable junk? Even Test equipment?

VERAULT

Veteran Member
Joined
Jan 30, 2012
Messages
8,485
Location
Connecticut, USA
I was finishing up a CRT repair and pulled out what has become my primary meter in the past years. An Extech EX530. I got it sometime around 2012 or 2013 I think as a backup meter at work. I found it to be a really good meter for the price.
Anyway I ws turning the rotary knob when it just came apart inside and was free spinning. I was livid. I wouldnt expect something 10 years old to fail so badly for what we paid for it.

I took the unit completely apart for the first time ever and this is what I found.
IMG_20230609_101932.jpg
The drive has a hexagon bit made of plastic which fits into a hexagon shaped hole on another rotary disc with metal fingers to make contact on which ever setting you have it set to.
IT rides clipped into a groove using two springs and two small ball bearings to make the tactile click. Unfortunately the entire mech is plastic.
I found the hexagon receptacle completely shattered. All 6 sides broke off into individual pieces. I spent an hour at least with tweezers and superglue just to get them back into the shape of the hexagon. Its no longer of equal size but it was the best I could do. I knew superglue had no chance of working. So once the super dried I added a small amount of epoxy resin to sort of force the hexagon shape to stay where it is.
IMG_20230609_101952.jpgIMG_20230609_101945.jpgIMG_20230609_122807.jpg
Unfortunatley there is no Keyway to determine where the knob should rest. I figured the diagnal line of empty space in the metal contacts must be the OFF position so I fought with assembling the knob mechanism. There is slight play now but its not terrible. The hardest part was snapping the back disk onto the front knob pushing the tiny ball bearings into a recess while the two clips lock onto the circle channel. I was able to get it working and inserted and the CLICK while turning is working.

I mostly assembled the meter just to see if the knob worked and if the screen still worked. I made the mistake of removing all the screws to the screen even though I didnt need to since the screws for removing the pcb and the lcd were all circled in white silkscreen. The screen had a zebra connector so I was pretty nervous getting it aligned would be trouble. But thankfully it wasnt.
The meter came back to life but the knob was on 180 degrees the opposite of what it was supposed to be. So I took the pcb out again and thankfully didnt have to dismantle the knob mechanism just free spin it 180 degrees then reinsert.
And that was it. IT went back together and tested good.
IMG_20230610_120545.jpg
The fact that this green plastic is already brittle means this will be a temporary fix. I dont know how long I will get but hopefully another year or two.
IMG_20230610_120330.jpg
Strangely enough I had to plastic weld the battery door about 5 years ago so I guess I just didnt see the signs of how terrible this plastic is.
IMG_20230610_120459.jpg
I always thought this thing has a pretty unique Serial number.


And to sum things up I think this logo was put on wrong from the factory. The trash bin should have been on the right side WITHOUT an X running through it.
IMG_20230610_120342.jpg
 
Last edited:
Well done, it would have been too easy just to bin it and buy another ... this is the better way of doing it!!! As you say, weird that the plastic is so brittle after only 10 years but on the other hand the boss around the hexagon looks really thin to start off with and is, of course, the highest stressed part of the meter.
 
I don’t want to find myself turning into one of those people that’s constantly bellyaching about how “things were better back in the day”, but I would swear that plastic today just isn’t the same as it used to be. It’s no doubt because the manufacturers are using less of some chemical that either costs too much or was found sometime around the year 2000 to turn rat livers into slurry just a little too quick for comfort, but, yeah, I swear that your “average” plastic dingus that wasn’t explicitly disposable used to hold up better over multi-year timespans. Seems like everything from kitchen tools on up gets brittle after only a year or two, even if you buy supposedly good brands.
 
I've had my yellow $NZ15 digital multi-meter for over 2 decades and only needed to replace the battery...IMG_20230611_073725.jpg
 
Last edited:
I remember we paid in the high $300's for this when it was new. I remember a few years later ravign about it recommending it to people and it got as low as $57.00 on sale (Weird I know). You can still find it but it seems to be up in the $200s again. At first it was great. Lots of options, True RMS like my long lost Fluke (RIP.. Somewhere) and temperature...
 
I just hope that most of these companies that squeeze the last few pennies out of the design spend more on under warranty returns than saved on components.
 
Got a few DMMs from the 1990s. Still work just fine. Haven't bought a new one since, although one of those DMM+scope ones look interesting. None was a name brand--one is a JDR Microdevices-branded one; another is from Circuit Specialists. Both made in Taiwan. Still have a VTVM that works fine.
 
Last edited:
I went back to using my 1981 Fluke 8024A in the interim. My backup for my backup. Yeah still works fine. In fact its continuity setting is so much snappier than the Extech's
 
I have a Radio Shack DMM from around 2001 that works fine. It has the yellow rubber case to maybe make it look like a Fluke. I have never had an issue with it and use it often. Still working fine.
 
Today's things are carefully designed to get through the warranty period and then fail shortly after. And, if it's made in China, there's no guarantee of anything.

I bought a yellow meter something like the one in the above photo, and it only worked once. After that, it says 0L on any voltage measurement. Lucky I have a spare meter.
 
And to sum things up I think this logo was put on wrong from the factory. The trash bin should have been on the right side WITHOUT an X running through it.

1686533919596.png

The X is meant to be there. The symbol is, without doubt, the company's marketing department trying to convince prospective buyers that the meter is not a piece of trash. :)
 
Exactly.. thsts why I thought it should definitely be removed.. or at the very least have a best by date. Not unlike fresh produce......
 
Back
Top